Skip to main content
Free Case Value Calculator

Insurance Bad Faith Claim Calculator

Calculate the potential value of an insurance bad faith claim. Our calculator accounts for your underlying claim amount, punitive damages eligibility, and your state's specific bad faith insurance laws.

Start Free Calculator

Quick & easy · Takes 2 minutes · 100% free

50 + DC
State-specific laws
16
Practice areas
100% Free
No signup required

Frequently Asked Questions

What Counts as Insurance Bad Faith

Insurers owe policyholders a duty of good faith. Bad faith is unreasonable claims handling — not merely a claim you disagree with.

  • Denial without investigation

    Rejecting a claim without a reasonable, prompt investigation of the facts.

  • Unreasonable delay

    Sitting on a valid claim or demanding endless, duplicative documentation.

  • Lowball offers

    Offering far less than a clearly-covered claim is worth, hoping you’ll give up.

  • Misrepresenting the policy

    Distorting coverage terms or your rights under the policy.

First-Party vs. Third-Party Bad Faith

First-party bad faith

Your own insurer mishandles your claim (a denied homeowner, health, disability, or UM/UIM claim). This is the most common type.

Third-party bad faith

A liability insurer mishandles a claim against you — for example, refusing a reasonable settlement within policy limits and exposing you to an excess judgment.

Why Bad Faith Is Worth More Than the Claim

  • The policy benefits

    The amount the insurer should have paid on the underlying claim.

  • Consequential & emotional damages

    Financial harm and distress caused by the wrongful denial or delay.

  • Punitive damages

    For egregious conduct, punitive damages can reach several multiples of the contract value — the main reason bad-faith cases are so valuable.

  • Attorney fees

    Many states award fees to a policyholder who proves bad faith.

Document Everything

Bad-faith cases are built on the paper trail.

Keep every denial letter, email, and claim note, and log every call (date, name, what was said). The insurer’s own internal claim file — obtained in discovery — is often the strongest evidence, revealing whether adjusters ignored their own experts or valuations. Deadlines usually run from the unreasonable denial, so act promptly.

Recommended Reading

Legal Disclaimer

Information on this page reflects current state laws as of 2026-03-07. This tool provides estimates for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Verify current rules with a licensed attorney before making decisions about your case. Learn about our methodology.

Browse by State

Select your state for a calculator using your state's specific laws.

Other Calculators

Ready to Find Out What Your Case Is Worth?

Answer a few questions about your situation. Our calculator uses state-specific laws and real case data to estimate your settlement value — free, private, and instant.

Calculate My Case Value